There is nothing in the world as good as FUDGE,
but . . .
It has to be creamy and silky smooth.
It can’t be sugary or grainy!
This fudge will pass that test . . . I promise.
I originally posted this recipe around Christmas time, when all the candy recipes come to the surface. I’ve had several emails from some who love Fudge, but can’t make fudge . . . and have asked for help! Since I only posted the recipe, I thought I would see if a few pictures could – or would make a difference for you.
I’ve decided that it’s very difficult to get a good picture of FUDGE. It might not look it, but this fudge recipe is silky smooth, and it simply melts in your mouth. You certainly don’t have to add the nuts, but in this house . . . we love nuts.
There are a few simple rules to making good fudge, and hopefully this tutorial will help.
~
1. I like to butter the inside edges of my pot – (these Martha Stewart Pots are wonderful)
2. Mix the cream and Sugar together over medium heat – stir continually.
3. Bring that mixture to a boil
4. Once the mixture comes to a full boil, place the lid on tightly for one full minute – time it.
When you take the lid off after one full minute . . . It will look like this.
5. After you have removed the lid – place a good thermometer in the pot.
Or if you don’t have one, you must cook this to a firm soft ball stage. (228 degrees)
IMPORTANT!! – DO NOT STIR NOW…..AT ALL!
6. While it’s cooking, break your chocolate bars up into a large bowl.
7. Prepare a greased or parchment paper lined glass baking dish. 9×13
*I like to place another pan inside the dish, so it helps to flatten our the parchment paper.
8. Cut 2 sticks (cubes) of butter into chunks
9. You can just get your hand mixer ready as well.
When the butter/cream mixture is at 228 degrees . . . Remove the pot from the heat.
DO NOT STIR! . . . at all.
Add the 1 cup of butter (2 sticks) and 1 tsp. Vanilla.
Let it sit quietly for 1 minute
DO NOT STIR!!!!!!!
After the 1 minute has passed – pour that mixture into your bowl with the broke up Chocolate pieces.
IMPORTANT!!! – DO NOT SCRAPE THE POT
*This is very vital in fudge making – you don’t want any sugar particles from the sides of that pot.
JUST POUR IT IN – DON’T SCRAPE THE SIDES.
Now you can beat it until is very smooth and creamy.
About four to five minutes. Taste it…..is is silky smooth?
If so, then it’s ready to pour into your greased or parchment lined pan.
UNLESS . . . you are adding nuts.
I like to do half and half. I don’t use two pans, I simply pour the plain fudge into the dish and tilt the pan slightly so that it stays to the left of the pan.
THEN . . . ADD NUTS TO THE REMAINING FUDGE.
Once the fudge is settled into the dish, cover it with Saran Wrap and then foil.
I like to place mine in the refrigerator for several hours, then it’s easier to cut.
If you’ve used Parchment, you can simply lift that entire slab of Fudge right out of the pan!
I trim the edges so that they are neat and straight.
*If you dip your sharp knife into a bit of hot water first, you can easily cut the fudge.
Clean off the knife if it gets built up with fudge, and start the process over until it’s all cut nicely.
Store the Fudge in between layers of waxed paper in a well sealed tupperware type container.
I keep mine in the fridge – It will stay perfect for several days.
FUDGE – Smooth as Silk
You will need:
3 – (6.8 oz) Symphony Bars
4 cups Sugar
2 Cups Cream





by Get Off Your Butt and BAKE
Krista - Hi Jonna,
Thanks so much for the recipe – I’m making this as we speak! I did notice though that towards the beginning of the recipe it calls for a teaspoon of vanilla, but the ingredients list reads a tablespoon of vanilla. Should it be a tablespoon? Thank you!!December 23, 2012 – 7:19 pm
Get Off Your Butt and BAKE! - Hi Ela,
Yes, you can substitute another brand of Chocolate….Lindt would be fabulous!
It doesn’t need to be refrigerated, and should ship very easily.
What a nice gift!
JonnaDecember 16, 2012 – 2:45 pm
Ela - Good looking fudge, yum! Can we subtitute other chocolates, for example, milk chocolate chips or Lindt chocolate bars as long as it equals 6.8 oz? One more question, I’d like to give this away for Christmas, will it melt if it isn’t refrigerated? I’d like to send it out of state? Thanks.December 15, 2012 – 10:08 pm
Cindi - How could you adapt this for peanut butter? or chocolate with peanut butter swirl?
Hi Cindi,
I betcha that you could just blend it in with your mixer at the same time you pour everything over the chocolate.
You might have to blend a little longer. I would try 1/3 cup…..let us all know!
Yum!
JonnaDecember 3, 2012 – 10:20 am
Autism News - The last time I attempted making fudge, it over flowed all over my stove top. Was it too hot maybe? Even turned down the heat and still couldn’t control. Any suggestions?!December 3, 2012 – 8:17 am
Roberta Boice - SO, that’s how you do it. I’ve been the recipient of this wonderful recipe for many a Christmas – DELICIOUS! Thanks Jonna-girl! AS ALWAYS, I love your site!December 2, 2012 – 4:58 pm
Marie - Hi Jonna
I am looking for a silky smooth fudge recipe like you buy at the Confectionery Stores. I would like to give your recipe a try. Since I live in Australia and ingredients can be different, I would appreciate knowing the measurements in ounces or grams for the weight of the butter.
Look forward to your response.
Hi Marie,
I will work on that….promise.
JonnaDecember 2, 2012 – 3:49 am
Susan Geyer - I can’t believe I have only found this recipe now! I have been stalking your site for absolute ages and somehow missed it.:D So sad! I have a question:- Would using dark chocolate change the outcome, (Meaning creaminess, smoothness)of the fudge? I do love dark chocolate fudge!
Regards Susan
Hi Susan,
As long as you use a high quality chocolate it will work.
The symphony results in a very creamy fudge.
I’ve used Hershey bars, and it’s good but not as creamy smooth.
Either way…it’s good!
JonnaDecember 1, 2012 – 5:27 am
Diane - I have made fudge from for years ..this looks easy can’t wait to try I was wondering do you use salted or unsalted butter. (I bake with unsalted)
Hi Diane,
I have used both, with great results!
It might seem odd to you, but I never buy unsalted butter!
JonnaDecember 1, 2012 – 2:48 am
Good Food Good Friends - I love making fudge. I can’t wait to try this recipe!November 30, 2012 – 4:49 am
Get Off Your Butt and BAKE! - Hi Trisha,
I betcha it’s still great…..less calories. It might not be quite as creamy though.
Let us all know.
JonnaNovember 29, 2012 – 3:22 pm
Trisha Preece - Jonna,
I should have read these comments before I started making the fudge. I had half and half in my fridge and used it in the recipe totally not thinking about what cream was. It looks like it’s going to set up okay, what do you think? Will it be okay? I am dying right now and could totally kick myself.November 29, 2012 – 3:12 pm
Get Off Your Butt and BAKE! - Hi Joni,
I use regular whipping cream or heavy whipping cream….either works perfectly!
JonnaNovember 29, 2012 – 10:46 am
Shelly B. - My favorite fudge EVER! Just bought my stock of candy bars last night! Holiday baking and candy making starts with this recipe!
November 29, 2012 – 9:45 am
Fathima - Thank you for all your wonderful Dishes. So yummy and love the pict. I want to make this fudge this year and never made fudge. what kind of cream do you use? WHipping cream? I get confused with creams when it comes to recipes. Sorry still learning
FathimaNovember 28, 2012 – 7:04 pm
JoniB - I am dying to make this fudge, what kind of cream do you use,
light cream, heavy cream, half & half?????
Thanks in advance.
Hi Joni
I use regular whipping cream or heavy whipping cream….either works perfectly!
JonnaNovember 28, 2012 – 4:12 pm
AnnO - I made this exactly like you show & it was AWESOME! I made it for Christmas gifts and EVERYONE said it was the creamiest they ever had. I’m not great in the kitchen – but, I thank you so much for these great recipes and pics. I will make this over and over again!December 30, 2011 – 7:14 pm
Chattipati - Use a good quality pizza cutter to cut your fudge into rows. It makes quick work of it and pieces turn out nicd and uniform. No need to butter or Pam the pizza cutter.December 28, 2011 – 12:34 pm
Sanna - Made this the other day and my hunt for the best fudge is over
ThanksDecember 10, 2011 – 10:19 pm
BreAna {Sugar and Spice and All Things Iced} - I absolutely love this fudge! I used chocolate chips instead of the symphony bars since I didn’t have any on hand. It turned out fantastic!December 8, 2011 – 10:07 am
Nikki H - Wow!!! I have made fudge for years and thought I’d perfected my own recipe which always turned out creamy, rich and deilcious, but took constant stirring & cooking on low or it would scorch. But now, after using this recipe, I’m throwing my other recipe away! This is by far the easiest, best tasting fudge ever …absolutely without equal! I even varied it by using white and green mint choc. chips to make mint fudge and added mini-marshmallows and nuts for rocky road. It works every single time and this year this fantastic fudge in original and the variations, was my gift to neighbors, friends and family!! Wow Again!January 10, 2011 – 4:23 pm
Anthi! - OHHH my God!!!!!!July 30, 2010 – 6:27 am
Barbara - That is perfect looking fudge! My family loves it too. Copying now.May 27, 2010 – 11:37 am
Kathy @ The Sugar Queen - I’m going to definitely try your recipe! I always use one that calls for marshmallow creme. This one looks fantastic!May 27, 2010 – 7:13 am
Shelly B. - This is THE BEST fudge EVER! I LOVE this recipe Jonna! Now I’m craving your fudge and it isn’t even Christmas!May 26, 2010 – 10:46 pm
Tauna - Good fudge has always eluded me. I will try this one!
Thanks for sharing!
I could spend hours here. You are amazing.May 26, 2010 – 9:59 pm
ingrid - Jonna, normally I agree with everything you say but with this one I have to disagree. (chocolate) Fudge is not the best!
LOL, this of course comes from a vanilla girl.
~ingridMay 26, 2010 – 10:26 am
Brandi - Oh your killing me!!! I LOVE your fudge, and am so jealouse that Chant got some of it for her trip to boise! mmmmmMay 26, 2010 – 10:18 am
jessica - I am so glad you posted this. I love your fudge.May 26, 2010 – 7:58 am
Steph - This looks super yummy! One question: above it says to “mix the cream and butter,” but at the bottom where the recipe is summarized it says “stir together the cream and SUGAR.” Which is correct?May 25, 2010 – 9:09 pm
Missy - Oh, I love fudge; I cannot wait to try this recipe. This looks absolutely perfect. Wonderful photos too!May 25, 2010 – 8:21 pm
Sherry - I’ve made easy types of fudge that require on use of the stove, but this looks batter than anything I’ve ever made!! I really need to try making fudge this way. And I’ll definitely add the nuts;)May 25, 2010 – 3:51 pm